On the nature of the epistemic readings of the Italian modal verbs: the relationship between propositionality and inferential discourse relations
نویسنده
چکیده
The present contribution deals with the epistemic readings of the Italian modal verbs dovere ('must') and potere ('may'/'can'). The two verbs show striking differences — both quantitative and qualitative — with respect to the possibility of epistemic interpretation, differences which have gone so far completely unnoticed in the — rather scarce — semantic literature on modal verbs in Italian. Even a cursory examination of corpus data shows that, contrary to standard assumptions, the occurrences of potere that are unambiguously to be interpreted epistemically, are much rarer than the epistemic/evidential readings of dovere, and, at least in the spoken language, tend to be limited to one particular syntactic pattern. A careful examination of the data shows that the epistemic readings of the two verbs differ systematically along two semantic dimensions: (1) The presence of an inferential evidential meaning and — consequently— the ability to function as trigger for the establishment of an inferential discourse relation between two discourse units (evidentiality). (2) The belonging of the modal predicate to the propositional (or truth-conditional) part of the meaning of an utterance or to the non propositional (non truth-conditional) part (propositionality). These observations, together with a reconsideration of the relationship between epistemic modality and deixis, lead us to conclude that the (so-called) "epistemic" interpretations of the verbs potere and dovere belong, in fact, to two semantically distinct kinds of modality and to hypothesise that they arise from different pragmatic processes.
منابع مشابه
A Comparative Analysis of Epistemic and Root Modality in Two selected English Books in the Field of Applied Linguistics Written by English Native and Iranian Non-native Writers
Academic discourse has always been the focus of many linguists, especially those who have been involved with English for Academic Purposes (EAP) and discourse analysis. Persuasion, as part of rhetorical structure of academic writing, is partly achieved by employing modality markers. Adopting a descriptive design, the present study was carried out to compare the use of modality markers in terms...
متن کاملLearning English Auxiliary Modal Verbs by Iranian Children
Modal verbs in English are challenging to learn by speakers of other languages. The purpose of thiswas to shed light on the use of gesture in learning English modal verbs by Persian-speaking children.To achieve this, 60 elementary Iranian learners, studying at some institutes in Karaj took part in thisstudy. The participants were randomly put into one experimental group and one control group. T...
متن کاملHow textbooks (and learners) get it wrong: A corpus study of modal auxiliary verbs
Many elements contribute to the relative difficulty in acquiring specific aspects of English as a foreign language (Goldschneider & DeKeyser, 2001). Modal auxiliary verbs (e.g. could, might), are examples of a structure that is difficult for many learners. Not only are they particularly complex semantically, but especially in the Malaysian context ...
متن کاملتحلیل روابط ایران و عراق بر اساس گفتمان ایرانهراسی
The framework of this essay is based on analyzing the bilateral relations between Iran and Iraq during the past 50 years. To reach the goal this study utilizes Discourse Theory of Laclau and Mouffe to examine the ruling discourses on the relations between the two countries from the outset of Saddam Hossein's leadership until now and to explain how and why the discourse of Iranophobia is dom...
متن کاملTeaching Modal Verbs: Task-based vs. traditional approaches
Abstract Task-based language teaching is considered an effective way to achieve a harmony between grammar and communication. The present study investigates two different ways of teaching modal verbs: task-based versus traditional approaches. To this purpose, an Oxford Placement Test was administered to select 40 homogeneous participants out of a larger population who took this test. The selecte...
متن کامل